10 Most Comfortable Dog Collars

10 Most Comfortable Dog Collars
This page may contain affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you make a purchase using these links.

Collars are essential items for dogs. They keep our four-legged family members safe. However, you also want them to be comfy! So, we’ve made a list of ten of the most comfortable dog collars on the market to help you out.

Whether your dog needs some extra cushioning and padding around their neck for safety reasons, or they’re just a pampered pooch, let’s break down exactly what to look for in comfy collars for dogs before we jump into our list.

If you already know what your dog wants, check out our buying guides for designer dog collars, leather dog collars, dog training collars, reflective collars for dogs, tactical collars, and collars for large dogs.

10 Most Comfortable Dog Collars

These are the ten most comfortable collars for dogs.

1. Soft Touch Collars Real Leather Luxury Padded Dog Collar

This leather collar by Soft Touch Collars comes in three sizes; small, medium, and large. The small option is 11 – 13.5 inches in length, the medium option is 14.5 – 17.5 inches, and the large option is 18 – 21 inches. They also come in six color options; black, brown, brown and pink, tan and coral, tan and teal, and turquoise and beige. They’re super stylish, high-quality, and feature internal padding for comfort.

The collars also come with easy-to-use metal buckles, D-rings, and a lifetime guarantee. The brand is a small, family-owned company based in California that really loves dogs and take pride in the quality and craftsmanship of their products. Reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with several buyers remarking on the quality of the item.

2. Joytale Reflective Dog Collar

Joytale‘s reflective dog collar is made of a soft, breathable, flexible neoprene material, and is padded for extra comfort. it comes in 12 fun colors; black, brown, grey, green, pastel pink, hot pink, navy blue, orange, red, sky blue, teal, and purple. It also comes in four sizes; extra small, small, medium, and large. The extra small size is 8 – 12 inches, the small option is 12 – 16 inches, the medium size is 14 – 20 inches, and the large option is 16 – 24 inches.

It has a curved plastic buckle to comfortably secure to your pet’s neck and comes with metal D-rings for ID tag and leash attachment. It also has light-reflective stitching for safety on night-time walks. The collar is super durable and quick-drying for swimming and wet weather adventures. It’s also an Amazon bestseller and super affordable, with several reviews calling it excellent value for money.

3. Poohoo Leather Soft & Breathable Padded Collar For Medium & Large Dogs

This super stylish leather collar by Poohoo uses breathable leather with soft PU lining supreme comfort. It has a fashionable bone pattern and comes in four colors; beige, red, brown, and grey. It also features a heavy-duty, rust-proof brass buckle and D-ring, and comes in three sizes for medium-large dogs. The medium size is 12.6 – 15.7 inches, the large size is 15.4 – 19.3 inches and the extra-large size is 19 – 23.7 inches.

The brand prides itself on handcrafting its products using traditional methods, durable materials, and quality hardware. This collar is also an Amazon bestseller and comes with a one-year warranty. Reviews are positive and several buyers mention the hardiness of the product.

4. Apasiri Dog Bow Tie Plaid Dog Collar

This plaid collar by Apasiri is adorable and comes with a detachable bow tie. It also comes in five cute colors; black and white, black and red, black and blue, black and green, and orange and grey. It’s made from soft, durable cotton and features buckles made of eco-friendly plastic and stainless steel D-rings.

The collar is also machine washable for easy cleaning and comes in three sizes; small, medium, and large. The small option is 9.6 – 14.8 inches, the medium is 12 – 18.7 inches, and the large is 14.8 – 23.6 inches. The bow ties are also hand-sewn and attached to the collar using an elastic strap.

Not only is this collar great for everyday life, family photos, gatherings, and events, but it also makes a great gift, too. It’s an Amazon’s Choice product and best-seller, as well as very affordable. Reviews absolutely love the sweet design.

5. AOLOVE Basic Classic Padded Leather Pet Collar

Aolove‘s leather collars come in five sizes and ten colors. The sizes range from 8 – 10 inches, 10.5 – 13 inches, 11.5 – 15 inches, 14.5. – 18.5 inches, and 17 – 22 inches in length. They’re available to buy in black, blue, brown, green, navy, pink, purple, red, rose, and yellow. It’s an Amazon best-seller and super affordable for genuine leather.

The collars also feature nickel-plated buckles and D-rings, and a padded interior for comfort. Reviews highly recommend the product.

6. BRONZEDOG Nylon Martingale Dog Collar

This martingale collar by BronzeDog comes in three sizes; small, which is 12 – 16 inches in length, medium, which is 15 – 19 inches in length, and large, which is 18 – 26 inches in length. It also comes in black, blue, green, orange, and pink. The collar is made from nylon with soft mesh padding on the inside for comfortable wear.

It’s also a best-seller on Amazon and reviews love the product, with several buyers saying how great it is for leash training young pups.

7. LoyalSunnyPet Cute Dog Collars For Girl Dogs

LoyalSunnyPet’s dog collars are made of a high-density polyester that is almost impossible to tear and as smooth and soft as grosgrain. It has a lightweight, quick-release plastic buckle. The collars come in several unique, bright, colorful, and feminine designs including floral patterns and watermelons.

They come in three size options; small-medium, medium-large, and large-extra large. The smallest option is 9.8 – 12.6 inches, the next size up is 12.0 – 18.1 inches, and the biggest option is 15.7 – 24 inches. There are also buying options to buy the collars with matching leads. It’s an Amazon best-seller and reviews absolutely love the pretty designs.

8. Link AKC Smart Dog Collar with GPS Tracker & Activity Monitor

This smart collar by Link comes complete with a nationwide GPS tracker and activity monitor that allows owners to set customized goals based on American Kennel Club insights. The brand likens it to a “smartphone for your dog” as it requires service plan connectivity to allow data to be transmitted, which can be bought in a subscription to the company, along with a SIM card, and 24/7 access to the pet poison helpline.

It also has sound-based training aids, LED lights for nighttime walks, temperature alerts that let you know if your dog’s environment is too hold or cold, an app that stores vet records, and a feature that lets you record, share, and remember special walks. All of which fits into a tiny smart tag so as to not add weight to your dog’s neck, unlike some other smart collars that use bulky devices.

There are two style options; black nylon and tan Italian leather. They’re both lightweight and naturally contoured to comfortably fit the curve of your dog’s neck. They are also waterproof and come in several sizes ranging from extra small to extra large. Reviews love the versatility of the product.

9. Paipaitek Vibrating Dog Training Collar

This vibrating dog collar by Paipaitek has two functions; beep and vibrate, no shocks, and no prongs. It is completely safe and humane. The one-size fit is fairly universal with an adjustable length of 8 – 26 inches and the single collar option comes in several colors including black and red. It’s made from lightweight and thin but durable nylon for a comfy fit and has reflective stitching for nighttime visibility.

The collar can be controlled via remote and there are over 200 settings to choose from. The remote reaches the collar from 3300 feet away and can work with up to three collars at once. Both the remote and the receiver on the collar are rechargeable via USB and can be charged at the same time.

It’s also waterproof and comes with a lifetime warranty. There are other buying options for packs of 2 or 3 collars in different colors for different dogs. The brand has ten years of experience in making professional standard pet training products and this one is no exception. It’s an Amazon best-seller and there are no bad reviews.

10. Challenger Floral Hand Tooled Padded Leather Dog Collar

This beautiful leather collar by Challenger comes in two sizes for medium-sized dogs; 16 – 20 inches and 17 – 21 inches. It comes in three striking design options; tan with yellow sunflowers and turquoise beaded inlay, pink sunflowers and white beads, or turquoise sunflowers and turquoise beads.

It’s handmade using superior quality, heavy-duty grain leather, that’s wider in the middle and padded on the inside for security and neck support, as well as a rust-proof D-ring and buckle. The collar comes with a lifetime guarantee and although it’s on the expensive side, it’s great value for the quality. Reviews say the wide design even works well with Greyhounds.

dog collars are legal requirements
By law, when a dog is in a public place, it must wear a collar.

The Importance Of Collars For Dogs

Dog collars don’t just sit around your dog’s neck looking pretty. By law, a dog must be wearing a collar carrying an ID tag when they are out in public. This should contain all of your contact information should they get lost. Collars also provide owners with control in dangerous situations, such as on busy roads and during confrontations with aggressive dogs.

You can start putting a collar on your dog at any age. In fact, it’s best to start early as they might find it uncomfortable at first, so it’s a good idea to get them used to it before they start going out on walks. Otherwise, they might be overwhelmed by the two things at once and associate going outside with feeling uncomfortable. You will need a puppy collar at first, but you should have a long-term adult-sized collar for your dog by the time they are 6 months of age.

Comfort

Although dog collars serve a serious purpose, they still need to be nice and comfortable for your dog to wear. For older dogs and dogs with breathing problems, it’s essential that they have collars that are thin, lightweight, and soft so as not to cause further discomfort. Pups that pull on the lead also need comfy collars that don’t constrict their breathing and hurt their necks. That said, all dogs should feel comfortable in their collars.

In order for your dog’s collar to be comfortable, it has to be the right size and material. When they are too small they can restrict a dog’s breathing, and when they are too big they could slip off on walks. Unless your dog is a Whippet or Greyhound, their collar should just be loose enough that you can slide a couple of fingers between the collar and their neck.

Before you buy your dog’s collar, measure their neck to ensure you buy the right size. To measure your dog’s neck, take a tape measure and place it around the circumference of the neck where the collar would sit, allowing space between two fingers. Don’t add extra space for Greyhounds and Whippets, just use the exact measurement.

The material of your dog’s collar should be lightweight, soft, and comfortable for your dog to wear, but also durable, weatherproof, and easy to clean for you. Leather and nylon are usually the best materials. If your dog has sensitive skin, collars that have padding or meshing on the inside will prevent irritation.

dog collar importance
Dog collars enhance the safety of the dog and its surroundings.

Type of Dog Collars

The type of collar you buy your dog is also important. There are a few different types and the one that’s right for you will depend on your dog’s needs. These are the most common kind of dog collars for everyday use – not including some of the more controversial training collars.

Flat Collars

Flat collars are the most common type of dog collar that we see every day. They sit flat against the neck and come with metal D-rings for attaching ID tags and leashes. These collars are great for regular dogs of all ages.

Martingale Collars

Martingale collars have a simple, clever design that tightens slightly when the dog wearing it pulls on the lead, discouraging the pulling behavior and encouraging good behavior when you’re out and about. They are not the same as controversial prong collars for aggressive dogs and are great for leash training adventurous puppies.

Leash training is important to ensure your dog knows how to behave on walks; walk calmly, have road safety, and interact well with strangers and other dogs.

Vibrating Collars

These collars vibrate at the touch of a button. They can act as a behavioral marker in training, which is the most effective method of dog training. The use of a marker helps dogs to identify their good behavior before they get a reward, to speed up the learning process. They can also be used to harmlessly identify negative behaviors, but they are not the same as controversial shock collars and do not cause any pain or fear.

They are highly recommended for training and communicating with dogs who have visual and hearing impairments, that rely more on touch than sight or sound to learn and communicate. You can use vibrating collars to train a sensory impaired dog to stop or come to you when the collar vibrates, and this can help to keep them safe whilst out on walks and avoid dangerous situations, like aggressive dogs.

Smart Collars

Smart collars are an invention of the modern age; they’re flat collars that are fitted with some kind of smart technology, usually GPS and health trackers, and sometimes other features too, like training aids and cameras. They are very helpful if you have a dog that is prone to wandering off and can be connected to an app on your phone for easy usage.

Other Things To Consider

As an owner, you may also want to consider:

  • The appearance of your dog’s collar
  • Buying from trusted brands
  • Products that use eco-friendly materials
  • Collars with extra safety features
  • High customer ratings and good reviews
dog martingale collars
This type of collar suits a dog breed that has a head narrower than its neck.

Comfy Collars for Dogs: FAQ

At what age should I put a collar on my dog?

You can start using a collar on your dog at any age. They might find it uncomfortable at first, so it’s a good idea to get them used to it before they start going out on walks. Otherwise, they might not enjoy their walks. You will need a puppy collar at first, but you should have a long-term adult-sized collar for your dog by around 6 months of age.

What is the best kind of collar for dogs?

The type of collar that’s right for you will depend on your dog’s needs. Flat collars sit flat against the neck and come with metal D-rings for attaching ID tags and leashes. They are great for regular dogs of all ages. Martingale collars tighten slightly when a dog pulls on the lead to discourage bad behaviors on walks and aid leash training.

Vibrating collars vibrate at the touch of a button to aid training and/or communication. They can act as a behavioral marker when training able-bodied dogs or as a method of communication for dogs with sight and hearing impairments. Smart collars are an invention of the modern age; they’re usually flat collars that are fitted with some kind of smart technology to help you keep track of your dog’s activities, location, and sometimes come with added features like training aids and cameras.

How do you measure a dog’s neck?

To measure your dog’s neck, take a tape measure and place it around the circumference of the neck where the collar would sit, allowing space between two fingers between the dog and the tape. Don’t add extra space for Greyhounds and Whippets, just use the exact measurement.

Are collars or harnesses better for dogs?

Harnesses and collars are both good options for dogs. Which one is better for you depends on your dog. Legally, all dogs must wear a collar with an ID tag when they are out in a public space, just in case something happens. However, you don’t have to attach your leash to it. Harnesses are great for leash control with dogs that pull and stop them from damaging their necks.

What should you put on your dog’s ID tag?

Owners should put their phone number and address on their dogs’ ID tags, or at least the city they live in if there’s not enough room to write the whole address. You can either put your own name or your dog’s name, but many experts advise not putting your dog’s name, as potential dog thieves can gain your dog’s trust by calling their name. You could also put a message about any medical or temperament information.

Those are our ten most comfortable collars for dogs. Will you be trying out one of our recommendations? Let us know in the comments down below!